Citizens Commission on Human Rights’ gripping documentary “Therapy or Torture: The Truth about Electroshock” exposes abuses in the $5.4 billion ECT industry.
Psychiatrists working for mental health facilities in the U.S. routinely seek court orders for individuals’ involuntary commitment to their facilities and for the forced psychiatric treatment of those patients, including forced drugging and electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), known more commonly as electroshock.
However some, including the Citizens Commission on Human Rights (CCHR), contend that ECT is torture, causes brain damage and is a human rights abuse. CCHR’s gripping documentary, Therapy or Torture: The Truth about Electroshock, reveals alarming facts about the $5.4 billion ECT industry.
Electroshock shoots up to 460 volts of raw electricity through brain tissue to induce a grand mal seizure, the most serious form of seizure, lasting up to 30 minutes. Hospital emergency room doctors treat grand mal seizures as a medical emergency. Psychiatrists call it “therapy.”
Even long-term shock doctors don’t know how much voltage it will take to produce a seizure in a patient. To put that voltage in context, a human brain is normally powered by a mere 0.2 of a volt of electricity – that’s eight times less electricity than a watch battery.
Psychiatrists admit they don’t know how ECT “works.” They don’t study the underlying science because there isn’t any. It’s trial and error with human lives.
According to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), electroshock can cause brain damage, cognitive impairment, permanent memory loss, prolonged or persistent seizures, worsening psychiatric symptoms, cardiovascular complications (including heart attacks), breathing complications, and death.
As psychiatrist Max Fink, M.D., considered the grandfather of electroshock in the U.S., coldly admitted: “The principal complications of ECT are death, brain damage, memory impairment and spontaneous seizures.”
Psychiatrists performing electroshock can live with that damage – and very profitably. It is estimated that a psychiatrist doing as few as 20 ECT sessions a week can bring in an additional $300,000 per year.
Most damning of all is the lack of scientific evidence behind it. Because the machines were grandfathered in when the FDA was first given authority to regulate medical devices, the manufacturers were never required to prove that electroshock machines and procedures are either safe or effective. CCHR believes the FDA relied upon biased studies in deciding to reduce the risk classification of the ECT device in its Final Rule in December 2018, allowing electroshock to become more widely available, despite not a single clinical trial proving that electroshock is either safe or effective.
CCHR wants Congress to investigate the FDA’s reliance on these studies and to demand all study data showing long-term risk. The investigation should include how those aged five and younger and the elderly are being electroshocked when no clinical trials support this. Research shows that senior citizens who received ECT died at over six times the rate of those who did not undergo it.
CCHR believes that coercive psychiatry’s practice of performing brain-damaging electroshock on emotionally vulnerable patients against their will is a cruel and degrading human rights violation that must be outlawed.
In a 2013 United Nations Human Rights Council report, Juan E. Méndez, then UN Special Rapporteur on Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman and Degrading Treatment or Punishment, agreed. His report analyzed torture and mistreatment commonly justified as health care treatment, and in its conclusions, called for “an absolute ban on all forced and non-consensual medical interventions against persons with disabilities, including the non-consensual administration of psychosurgery, electroshock and mind-altering drugs….”
A 2018 U.N. Human Rights Council report also called on governments to recognize forced psychiatric treatment, including electroshock, as “practices constituting torture or other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment….”
CCHR has posted an online petition, which has over 122,000 signers supporting a complete ban on electroshock. Since 1969, CCHR has helped obtain more than 180 laws that protect mental health patients, including laws requiring informed consent for ECT and laws prohibiting it for minors in some states.
The Citizens Commission on Human Rights National Affairs Office in Washington, DC, has advocated for mental health rights at the state and federal level. The CCHR traveling exhibit has been displayed in Washington, DC, at the Congressional Black Caucus Foundation Annual Legislative Conference and other locations. The exhibit has toured more than 441 major cities around the world and has educated over 800,000 people on the history and contemporary practices of psychiatry which are still rampant with abuse.
CCHR is a nonprofit, non-political, non-religious mental health watchdog. Its mission is to eradicate abuses committed under the guise of mental health and to enact patient and consumer protections. CCHR was co-founded in 1969 by the Church of Scientology and Professor of Psychiatry Emeritus Dr. Thomas Szasz.